Assisted Deaths Prior to the Voluntary Assisted Dying Act 2017 (Vic): Would Patients Have Met the Eligibility Criteria to Request Voluntary Assisted Dying?

Willmott L, Feeney R, Del Villar K, Chambaere K, Yates P, Mitchell G, White B. Assisted Deaths Prior to the Voluntary Assisted Dying Act 2017 (Vic): Would Patients Have Met the Eligibility Criteria to Request Voluntary Assisted Dying? J Law Med. 2022 Aug;29(3):811-828.

ABSTRACT

Unlawful assisted dying practices have been reported in Australia for decades. Voluntary assisted dying (VAD) is now lawful in Victoria and Western Australia in limited circumstances and will soon be lawful in a further four Australian States. This article examines nine cases involving unlawful assisted dying practices in Victoria in the 12 months prior to the commencement of the Voluntary Assisted Dying Act 2017 (Vic) in 2019. It explores whether, if that Act had been in operation at the relevant time, these patients would have been eligible to request VAD, having regard to their decision-making capacity and their disease, illness or medical condition. Many of these patients would not have been eligible to request VAD had the legislation been operational, primarily because they lacked decision-making capacity. As VAD is lawful only in a narrow set of circumstances, unlawful assisted deaths may continue to occur in those States where voluntary assisted dying is legal.